How the Post and Courier is turning subscriber retention into a growth strategy

For many publishers today, subscription growth is no longer just about attracting new readers — it’s about keeping the ones you already have. At The Post and Courier in South Carolina, that reality has reshaped how the company approaches reader revenue. President of Newspaper Operations PJ Browning and Subscriber Experience Manager Mary Fox have built a strategy that treats retention not as a back-office function but as a core part of the business.

Working alongside marketing partner Newspaper Subscription Services (NSS), the organization has developed a structured subscriber lifecycle that focuses on habit formation, proactive engagement and targeted win-back strategies. The approach has helped the Post and Courier drive unusually low churn while expanding its newsroom footprint across the state.

“Today what we’re faced with from a publisher standpoint is just the noise that’s out there,” Browning said. “Content is king, but platforms and distribution is King Kong.” For Browning and her team, that environment makes retention as critical as acquisition.

Building a statewide news model supported by subscriber revenue

The Post and Courier’s subscription strategy is tied directly to its broader journalism mission. During the COVID era, Browning said the organization began expanding aggressively across South Carolina, stepping into communities where local journalism was disappearing. "We started seeing news deserts form throughout the state,” Browning said. “So it was really, how do we set up local news organizations across the state?”

Today the company operates nine expansion markets and eight community newspapers while sharing investigative journalism and specialized reporting across the network. Sustaining that growth requires a stable base of subscriber revenue — which is why retention has become a central operational focus. “Our churn rate will range anywhere from 1.9% to 2.2%,” Browning said. “And that just means we’re doing the right things for people who want to stay engaged with us.”

That work is led by Fox, whose role spans subscriber experience, retention marketing and customer service strategy. “I want to reach subscribers where they are and give them content, give them benefits and give them whatever is going to be the most valuable to them so that they keep coming back and reading our publication,” Fox said.

Turning retention into a newsroom-wide discipline

At the Post and Courier, retention is not confined to marketing. Browning said the organization treats subscriber engagement as a shared responsibility across departments, including the newsroom. “We do not do things and put them on a shelf,” Browning said. “This is a live active document.”

Retention metrics are reviewed weekly by the digital team, while the broader organization receives regular updates on performance. The newsroom is also closely tied into that process through audience analytics. “Each reporter has their own individual dashboard so they can see how they’re performing,” Browning said.

That data has helped the newsroom understand what resonates with readers while maintaining its commitment to public-interest journalism. “You just can’t spend the same amount of time on something people aren’t going to read,” Browning said. “It doesn’t mean it shouldn’t exist, but you have to manage how you cover it.”

Fox said the data-driven approach helps both sides of the organization work toward the same goal: building reader habits. “Our main focus is on habit formation,” she said.

Proactive retention starts before a subscriber ever cancels

Fox believes many publishers approach retention too late — focusing only on the moment a reader decides to cancel. “We need to be proactive,” she said. “We need to start from the beginning before somebody’s ever subscribed.”

That philosophy shapes the Post and Courier’s subscriber journey, which includes onboarding campaigns, targeted messaging and ongoing reminders of the value subscribers receive. “We constantly remind subscribers of the value so they don’t get to the end of their subscription and say, ‘I don’t know what I just paid for,’” Fox said.

Executing that strategy efficiently requires tools that allow the team to analyze subscriber behavior and automate campaigns. The Post and Courier works with Newspaper Subscription Services (NSS) to support many of those efforts, including subscriber acquisition marketing, cancellation intervention and win-back campaigns.

NSS integrates directly with the paper’s circulation system, allowing subscription transactions and retention actions to flow automatically into the publisher’s database. That automation helps Fox’s team focus more on strategy and less on administrative tasks. “We don’t have a large team,” Fox said. “I used to say retention party of one.”

With NSS functioning as what she described as an extension of the team, the organization can test campaigns, analyze results and pivot quickly.

Download the slides used during the live broadcast

Reducing cancellations through smarter subscriber engagement

One of the most effective tools in the Post and Courier’s retention strategy is a structured online cancellation flow supported by NSS technology.

When subscribers attempt to cancel, they are asked to identify the reason for leaving. That information allows the system to present targeted responses designed to address the concern — whether it involves price, content usage or product experience. The approach has produced measurable results. “Our online save rate currently is at 30%,” Fox said.

Even when subscribers do leave, the organization works aggressively to bring them back. Segmented win-back campaigns supported by NSS allow the team to tailor messages based on how and why the reader canceled. “We approach each of our subscribers in the way that they left us,” Fox said.

Those targeted campaigns have delivered strong results, with some individual win-back emails converting former subscribers at rates as high as 50%. Fox also emphasizes that not all retention tactics rely on discounts. “It’s not always discounting,” she said. “You can use the value of your product and lean into that.”

Why pricing strategy matters for retention

That belief in value shapes the Post and Courier’s pricing strategy as well. Fox said the organization approaches subscriptions with confidence in the product it produces. “We feel strongly that our product is valuable,” she said. “We have very high-quality, in-depth journalism.”

Rather than relying on deep discounts to attract subscribers, the company focuses on reinforcing value through onboarding, newsletters and ongoing engagement. “When you give your subscription away for very low, you’re telling people it’s not worth any more than that,” Fox said.

Browning agrees that low introductory pricing often leads to higher churn. “What doesn’t work for us is when we do a lowball rate,” she said. “We’re setting the wrong precedent.” Instead, she said higher-value subscribers tend to stay longer. “When people pay more, they are more likely to stay with us,” Browning said.

Retention improvements also have a direct financial impact. Because the company budgets for churn each month, even modest improvements can generate meaningful revenue gains. “Being able to improve that churn rate is probably a $30,000 lift just for the month,” Browning said. “It has a direct financial impact.”

A partnership model built around publisher success

For NSS, supporting publishers like the Post and Courier means working as an extension of the internal team rather than replacing it. “At NSS we believe in keeping things simple,” said Lon Haenel, the company’s chief client officer.

The company’s platform supports subscriber acquisition, retention marketing, cancellation intervention and win-back campaigns. Its pricing model is designed to align with publisher performance. “When you do better, we do better,” Haenel said. “You truly only pay for results.”

That approach has helped the company build long-term relationships with publishers across the industry. “Service is really the foundation that NSS was built on,” Haenel said.

For Browning and Fox, the partnership has helped them scale their retention strategy without expanding internal staffing. The larger lesson, Fox said, is that retention cannot be treated as an afterthought.

“You’ve got to make time,” she said. Browning was even more direct about what publishers should do if they want to strengthen reader revenue. “Hire a Mary,” she said.

For the Post and Courier, that investment — supported by the right tools and partnerships — has turned subscriber retention into one of the company’s most powerful growth drivers.

About NSS